Archive for May 2015

Whole30 Doubts and Concerns

leave a comment »

So, having done some reading and thinking about the Whole30 diet, there are some things that rub me the wrong way about it. I’m sure there are rebuttals to each and every one of these points, and I strongly believe that as a whole, this diet is almost guaranteed to be positive, but I wanted to express the doubts I’ve had about it before starting.

  • The all-or-nothing approach. OK, it’s just supposed to be for 30 days, but I’m generally in favor of diets that can easily work as long-term lifestyles as well, and that allow for human weakness and minor slip-ups. The site states: “The only way this will work is if you give it the full thirty days: no cheats, slips, or ‘special occasions.’ This isn’t us playing the tough guy. This is a fact, born of education and experience. You need such a small amount of any of these inflammatory foods to break the healing cycle—one bite of pizza, one splash of milk in your coffee, one lick of the spoon mixing the batter within the 30 day period and you’ve broken the ‘reset’ button, requiring you to start over again on Day 1.” 30 days is an arbitrary amount of time, and the idea of one little slip-up ruining everything is very discouraging. I suppose if you really have an undiagnosed food allergy, eating something you’re allergic to will mess things up for you temporarily, but I do not believe the body runs on exact 30-day reset cycles, and I don’t see any evidence for why this hardline attitude is necessary aside from the Whole30 team saying in an authoritative voice that This Is How It Works. I guess this helps people who aren’t able to take a shades-of-gray approach to diets, who need hard-and-fast, black-and-white, all-or-nothing rules, but I resent and chafe at this type of approach unless it’s scientifically justified.
  • Privilege. This diet, like so many others, comes from a place of unthinking socioeconomic privilege. In preparing for this, we spent $10.50 on a jar of organic coconut butter. We bought a little tub of fresh-ground almond butter that cost about four times as much as the fresh-ground peanut butter. We made ghee from grass-fed butter that cost about four times as much as the regular store-bought butter. We spent fifteen minutes looking at the labels of various nut, coconut, and hempseed milks at the co-op looking for one without carrageenan. (I still don’t really understand why carrageenan is banned–off to research this after this post.) I’m well aware that I am lucky enough to have the spare time and money to do this experiment. “Uber-restrictive diet aimed at reducing inflammation in the body because maybe you are sensitive to some of these common food allergens,” or whatever the actual narrative is for the Whole30 diet, may relate to food, but it’s actually somewhere way up at the top of Maslow’s pyramid. No, it’s not impossible to follow the Whole30 on a limited time/money budget, but I’m basically eliminating every convenient, cheap food I have ready access to if I don’t feel like cooking, ignoring half my pantry, and putting myself in a position where I need to buy expensive, hard-to-get substitutes for cheap staples like flour and milk in order to follow the diet more easily. Sure, eggs and potatoes and vegetables are cheap, but you also need the time to cook these things, and if you’re working two jobs or you have a picky kid you need to cook something else for, or any number of other reasons, that may not be feasible. Because we live in an unfair world and I already live in a privilege bubble, I guess this isn’t really a problem so much as something that sort of bothers me and that I feel obliged to point out.
  • The profit motive combined with some seemingly arbitrary restrictions that place the Whole30 team in a position of authority. I pretty much fully understand the reasoning behind vegan, raw vegan, or paleo diets. I do not fully understand all the reasoning or guidelines behind the Whole30 diet, and that makes me uneasy, because by deciding to follow the diet, I am now beholden to an authority figure that doles out rulings on what is OK and what isn’t. Yes, I know that the basic Whole30 is free, but as rulers of the Whole9 media empire, the Whole30 team has a vested interest in being able to tell people that potatoes are banned one day and OK the next, like parents or popes. BECAUSE I SAID SO, THAT’S WHY. Follow my blog and buy my book to always have the latest and greatest!
  • This whole “sex with your pants on” thing/”following the spirit of the guidelines”. As a corollary, mushy guidelines based on psychological control rather than nutritional realities. Although they claim the ban on “imitation” foods is in order to breed a healthy relationship to food, to me, it actually smacks of orthorexia and an unhealthy relationship with food, as well as a reliance on the Whole30 plan as arbiter. This part of the diet actually really bothers me. Part of the Whole30 diet involves cutting out Paleo substitutes for unhealthy foods, even if they’re made with “approved” ingredients, in order to eliminate cravings and allegedly reset your relationship to food. They state that a portobello mushroom cap instead of a burger bun is an OK swap, but a paleo-style coffee creamer is not. “Regarding “Paleo” coffee creamer… sigh. We know there’s a recipe out there where eggs, coconut milk, dates, and some voodoo magic are combined with prayers to create a thick, creamy concoction that can take the place of your cream and sugar (or Coffeemate) and once again transform your undrinkable black coffee into sweet, dreamy caffeine. This is not okay–sugary creamer substitutes fall under the SWYPO rule. Instead, we’d encourage you to take a look at why you need this at all. Do you really like coffee, or are you drinking it for the hit of sugary flavor?” I never sweeten my coffee, but let me ask: is this diet actually about eliminating foods that have a certain physical effect on your body? Or is this a diet that’s actually about the virtues of self-denial according to a set of semi-arbitrary rules? They also state on the SWYPO page: “In addition, context matters. For example, the amazing fried chicken in Paleo Comfort Foods is a perfectly appropriate (and delicious) dinner choice while on your Whole30. However, if you’re coming off a wicked addiction to KFC, perhaps Jules & Charles’ creation isn’t the best choice for you during your program. Make sense?” I suppose I understand this in the context of individual people’s cravings and what foods might make them, personally, most likely to cheat on their diet–and only in that context–but banning all dessert substitutes is a one-size-fits-all approach that annoys me. I feel that it’s healthy to enjoy your food, and if you must give up an entire category of foods that brings you pleasure, with foods you enjoy more being even more off limits, something seems wrong to me about your relationship to your food at that point. First of all, I’d prefer to see a purely nutrition-based approach to which foods are allowable, but secondly, I would prefer to see a focus on really learning to enjoy healthier versions of foods rather than denying any food that might possibly remind you of another food that’s even better. To put this in a personal context, there’s a dessert recipe I really like to make sometimes, a chocolate chia seed pudding topped with whipped coconut cream. I’m pretty sure this is banned on the SWYPO principle, and because it contains agave, but for argument’s sake, if I were to add dates to sweeten it instead: why can my desire for this food not be seen as healthy enjoyment of a delicious food for its own sake rather than unhealthy cravings for a “better” dessert? I feel that this approach sets up a framework where a food is bad if you like it too much–a sort of guilt-based metric that rewards self-denial, and I don’t think that idea is healthy at all.

Anyway, bottom line: I do believe this is a healthy diet on the whole, or I wouldn’t have agreed to try it. But the points above gave me pause, and will probably continue to do so as I embark on my 30 days. Follow my whole30 tag or just follow along with the blog for the next 30 days if you want to read more.


Written by orata

May 31, 2015 at 1:39 pm

Posted in whole30

Tagged with

Changing My Life in 30 Days? The Whole30 Diet

leave a comment »


I’ve been writing this food blog for almost 13 years now, but up until now, it’s always been more of a personal food journal, a place to stow recipes, than a public-facing site directed at anyone besides myself. However, this month, I’m planning to do the Whole30 diet with my husband and I’m pretty sure the only way I can stay motivated is by documenting it obsessively and making myself publicly accountable. This diet involves cutting out a number of common “problem foods”–grain, alcohol, sugar, dairy, legumes–for 30 days, as sort of a cross between an elimination diet and cult deprogramming. From the official website: “Cut out all the psychologically unhealthy, hormone-unbalancing, gut-disrupting, inflammatory food groups for a full 30 days. Let your body heal and recover from whatever effects those foods may be causing. Push the ‘reset’ button with your metabolism, systemic inflammation, and the downstream effects of the food choices you’ve been making.”

A little background: my diet hovers somewhere in a pragmatic zone between SAD and chowhound. Your impression of my diet will be vastly skewed if you look through my blog archives–I don’t write about the Chicken McNuggets or mac ‘n’ cheese pizza I eat on a regular basis, but they’re there. My lunch on a typical day might be scrambled eggs with roasted vegetables, but it might just as easily be a bowl of ramen. I know I eat a lot of foods that are bad for me, but they’re also convenient and delicious. I’m food-obsessed and knowledgable about food, but I’m not really a food snob, so fast food and restaurant food make their way into my mouth just as often as high-quality home-cooked meals.

I’m not actually terribly enthused about the Whole30 diet, for a few reasons I’ll get into more in my next post. So why am I doing it? My husband Rahul got very enthusiastic about it after reading about our friend Josh’s experiences with the diet–currently on day 15 or thereabouts, Josh has been posting regular glowing reviews of it on Facebook. So Rahul really wanted to do the diet for various reasons–to quell various aches and pains, asthma symptoms, fatigue, sluggishness, and to lose weight. I reluctantly agreed to try it with him, although giving up grains, dairy, beans, alcohol, and sugar for a month in the middle of summer seems like pure torture. However, I’ve been feeling pretty fat and sluggish myself, having spent basically all winter and most of spring eating fatty foods and not exercising (we spent our winter break in Quebec, eating poutine and Montreal bagels, and Easter weekend in New Orleans, land of beignets and deep-fried seafood), and the thought of having the opportunity to press the reset button on my health and potentially change the way I look and feel in a short period of time, without crash dieting, seemed pretty tempting.

Still. 30 days without some of the most delicious things life has to offer!–dark beer, Greek yogurt with honey, sushi, deep-fried cheese curds, pad thai, barbecued pork buns, Haagen-Dasz Vanilla Swiss Almond ice cream, peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, and even some less obvious treats like the tempeh-and-white-bean vegan biscuits and gravy I make on Sunday mornings sometimes, or scrambled eggs with soy sauce and sugar–this is going to be tough. I don’t have that much of a sweet tooth, fortunately. I figure I can find savory indulgences far more easily than sweet ones on this diet. And thank God potatoes are allowed on the Whole30 diet.

We’ve made some preparations for the diet already–with my mother-in-law’s help, we made a jar of ghee from expensive grass-fed Kerrygold butter (this is the only dairy permissible, according to the guidelines); we bought some coconut flour and coconut butter, the latter of which I have already started eating because it tastes absolutely wonderful, like the inside of a Mounds bar; I ordered a spiralizer from Amazon because one of my favorite healthy meals involves shredding up zucchini and carrots with a julienne peeler and eating them with tomato sauce, and spiralized veggies seem even easier and better than julienned shreds, not to mention fun to make. We keep fresh veggies, eggs, and meat around regularly anyway, so we won’t have to do too much in terms of stocking our fridge with those.

This week I’ve been slowly saying goodbye to all the foods I’ll miss during the month of June, and resisting the urge to gorge on as many of them as possible in the limited time I have left. I made a kale pasta gratin to use up a bunch of our cheese (farewell, cheese and pasta); I ate a bowl of Greek yogurt with almond butter and coconut butter (goodbye, yogurt); we polished off a bag of Rice Krispie treats from my mother-in-law (so long, sugar and rice).

Wish me luck. I’ll post tomorrow about some doubts I have about this diet, aside from “OMG all the delicious foooooods I’m missing!” Follow the whole30 tag for all my posts about it.

Written by orata

May 30, 2015 at 12:15 pm

Posted in whole30

Tagged with

kale pasta gratin

with one comment

Inspired by the wild rice gratin from the Smitten Kitchen cookbook:

Cook about 1/2 cup of mafalda pasta in boiling salted water according to the package directions, till just shy of al dente. Reserve about 3/4 cup of the pasta cooking water.

Saute 1 sweet onion in butter and oil with salt and pepper until golden, in a large cast-iron skillet, then add the chopped leaves of one large bunch of kale to the pan (kale is 99 cents a bunch at the Taylorville, IL Wal-Mart!) Add the pasta cooking water, stir, and cook till the kale is wilted. Stir in the pasta and about 1/2 cup of chopped or grated cheese (I was using up the leftover cheese in the fridge, so this was a mix of dill-flavored white cheddar and mozzarella), along with about a tablespoon of chopped fresh oregano. Top with about 1/4 cup chopped or grated cheese and breadcrumbs; dot with butter. Bake at 450 for about 5-10 minutes, until the breadcrumbs are golden and the cheese is melted.


I think this would have been good with some red pepper flakes as well.

Written by orata

May 26, 2015 at 1:17 pm

Posted in recipes

Tagged with